Seven Trump Judicial Nominees Would Not Say Biden Won in 2020 or That the Capitol Was Attacked on January 6
At a November 18 Senate Judiciary Committee hearing on seven of President Trump's nominees for lifetime appointments to the federal bench, every nominee declined to state two settled facts, and a Texas Supreme Court justice nominated to a federal district court could not recall what the 22nd Amendment says before declining to say whether Trump can run for a third term.
POLITICS
11/19/20265 min read


Photo: Architect of the Capitol / Public domain
Seven of President Donald Trump's nominees for lifetime seats on the federal bench appeared before the Senate Judiciary Committee on Wednesday, November 18, and all seven declined to say that Joe Biden won the 2020 presidential election. All seven also declined to say that the United States Capitol was attacked on January 6, 2021 (Nomination Notes, November 18, 2026: https://nominationnotes.substack.com/p/seven-judicial-nominees-refuse-to).
THE DETAILS
The first panel considered James Cody Hiland, the nominee for the United States Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit. The second panel considered six district court nominees... Philip Aubart for the Middle District of North Carolina, Joseph Falvey for the Northern District of Indiana, Eric Hamilton for the District of Nebraska, Grayson Lambert for the District of South Carolina, Brian Meyers for the Eastern District of North Carolina, and James P. Sullivan for the Western District of Texas (Nomination Notes, November 18, 2026).
Senator Richard Blumenthal asked all seven nominees who won the 2020 election, a question he uses to test independence and truth telling. Hiland answered that "Joe Biden received the electoral vote and was certified by this Congress as president of the United States and served four years as president," and, asked who won the popular vote, answered that "the popular vote is not what's important, respectfully. I mean, it's the Electoral College" (Nomination Notes, November 18, 2026). The six district nominees gave versions of the same answer, describing certification through the Electoral College while declining to say Biden won. When Blumenthal asked the six district nominees if anyone was willing to say the Capitol was attacked on January 6, the room filled with silence. "Nobody. It's a sad day," he said (Nomination Notes, November 18, 2026).
The hearing's most striking exchange came on the Constitution itself. Senator Chris Coons asked Sullivan, a justice of the Texas Supreme Court, "can you just tell me what the 22nd Amendment provides?" Sullivan struggled, saying he carried it "over my heart because sometimes it isn't in my brain," then paused and said, "Oh boy, oh boy." Coons supplied the opening words, "No person shall be elected," and Sullivan completed the thought... "No person shall be elected more than twice" (People, November 18, 2026: https://people.com/trump-nominated-judge-refuses-to-say-he-cant-run-for-third-term-12263450). Asked whether that bars Trump, who has been elected twice, from running again in 2028, Sullivan declined, saying it would be "a violation I believe of Canon 5 for me to opine on something like that" and calling the question "the sort of thing that is a subject of ongoing political debate" (People, November 18, 2026; Nomination Notes, November 18, 2026).
Coons answered that the amendment "is bracingly clear" and that the question "is only unresolved in the mind of President Trump" (People, November 18, 2026). Two of Sullivan's fellow nominees then answered the same question directly. Lambert said "the text of the 22nd Amendment seems clear" that no one can serve a third term, including Trump, and Falvey said, "President Trump is a person subject to the 22nd Amendment" (Nomination Notes, November 18, 2026).
BACKGROUND AND CONTEXT
The hearing itself broke the committee's own norms. It took place just eight days after the committee's last nominations hearing, and it included nominees whose questionnaires had been received less than 28 days earlier. Ranking Member Dick Durbin said the one week turnaround on Hiland's paperwork was the shortest he had experienced in nearly three decades on the committee, and Coons said senators typically get a month to review questionnaires (Nomination Notes, November 18, 2026). Senator Cory Booker criticized what he called a "post election race to get people on the bench" in states where incoming Democratic senators would likely want a role in choosing judges (Nomination Notes, November 18, 2026).
Sullivan reached the hearing by an unusual path. Governor Greg Abbott appointed him to the Texas Supreme Court in January 2025, Texas voters declined to keep him there in this month's election, and Trump then nominated him to a lifetime seat on the federal district court (People, November 18, 2026; Nomination Notes, November 18, 2026). Trump has repeatedly mused about a third term, at one point saying there were "methods" he could pursue, before acknowledging in October 2025 that he would not legally be able to run again, and then teasing the idea again the following month (People, November 18, 2026).
WHY THIS MATTERS
Federal district judges serve for life. The men and women confirmed from this panel will rule on election disputes, voting rights, criminal cases arising from political violence, and challenges to presidential power, in some cases for decades. Blumenthal stated the stakes plainly at the hearing: "You are going to be the voice and face of justice to anybody who appears in your courtroom if you are confirmed. And they're relying on your objectivity and resistance to any political loyalty test, which is, unfortunately, what you're demonstrating here" (Nomination Notes, November 18, 2026).
The documented pattern matters more than any single answer. A nominee who will not state who won an election that has been certified, counted and litigated for six years is telling the Senate how he will handle facts that carry a political cost. That is information voters in Texas, Indiana, Nebraska and the Carolinas will live with long after this news cycle ends.
THE POLITICAL PERSPECTIVE
Democrats on the committee treated the refusals as a loyalty test administered by the White House and passed by silence. The record gives them material to work with... Hiland resigned as a United States Attorney after Trump's 2020 defeat, an act that acknowledged the result at the time, yet would not state the result as a nominee (Nomination Notes, November 18, 2026). The contrast inside the panel itself is also part of the record. Lambert and Falvey answered the third term question directly and suffered no visible consequence for it, which undercuts the claim that the question could not be answered.
THE OTHER SIDE
The nominees' stated reason was judicial ethics. Canon 5 of the judicial conduct code provides that a judge or judicial candidate shall refrain from inappropriate political activity, and several nominees said that questions about contested elections implicate matters of public and political controversy that could come before them (People, November 18, 2026; Nomination Notes, November 18, 2026). Their answers on certification were also literally accurate as far as they went... Biden was certified the winner through the Electoral College, which is how presidents are selected. Republicans on the committee praised the nominees, with Senator John Boozman calling Hiland "outstanding" and Senator Tom Cotton commending Trump's "excellent choice" (Nomination Notes, November 18, 2026). Coons addressed the ethics argument directly, saying he respects the canon but that it covers matters "genuinely the subject of ongoing jurisprudential debate. This is not that" (Nomination Notes, November 18, 2026).
WHAT HAPPENS NEXT
The nominations now move toward committee votes and then the full Senate. Democrats take control of Congress on January 3, 2027, which is the deadline pressure behind the accelerated schedule Democrats criticized at the hearing. The unanswered questions are practical ones... whether any Republican senator treats the refusals as disqualifying, and whether the committee's abandoned review timelines become the new standard for lifetime appointments.
SOURCES AND DOCUMENTATION
Nomination Notes, "Seven judicial nominees refuse to say that Joe Biden won the 2020 election," November 18, 2026. Supports the hearing's composition, the norm violations, every nominee's answers on 2020 and January 6, the Sullivan exchange, and the Lambert and Falvey answers. https://nominationnotes.substack.com/p/seven-judicial-nominees-refuse-to
People, "Trump Nominated Judge Refuses to Say the President Can't Run for a Third Term," November 18, 2026. Supports the Coons and Sullivan exchange in detail, the Canon 5 explanation, Coons's response, Sullivan's background, and Trump's third term remarks. https://people.com/trump-nominated-judge-refuses-to-say-he-cant-run-for-third-term-12263450
Fact check note: This is a developing story. The nominees have not yet faced a committee vote, and nothing in this article predicts the outcome of any nomination. All quotations are drawn from the hearing record as reported by the two sources above, which agree on the substance of the exchanges.
WEAR YOUR VOICE
Rejecting Kings T-Shirt ($32)
Follow


Privacy Policy · Terms and Conditions · Refund Policy · Shipping Info
© 2025 My Voice Ofc. All rights reserved.
