Supreme Court Takes Up Trump's Asylum Ban, a Policy Two Courts Called Illegal

The justices agreed on November 13 to hear Mullin v. Refugee and Immigrant Center for Education and Legal Services, and the ban stays in effect while they decide whether a president can suspend a right Congress wrote into law.

IMMIGRATION

11/15/20266 min read

Photo via Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 3.0)

The Supreme Court agreed on Friday, November 13, to decide whether President Donald Trump can suspend access to asylum at the United States Mexico border by declaring an invasion, taking up a case that will test how far a president can go in setting aside immigration protections Congress enacted. The case is Mullin v. Refugee and Immigrant Center for Education and Legal Services, No. 26 239. In its November 13 order list, the Court wrote that the petition is granted limited to the first two questions presented, covering whether the proclamation and its implementing guidance are lawful and whether federal law bars the class wide relief a lower court ordered (Supreme Court order list, November 13, 2026). The policy remains in effect while the case is pending, so asylum stays closed at the border for now, with a decision expected by the end of June 2027 according to SCOTUSblog reporting.

THE DETAILS

On January 20, 2025, his first day back in office, President Trump issued Proclamation 10888, titled Guaranteeing the States Protection Against Invasion. The proclamation declared that an invasion is ongoing at the southern border and suspended the entry of noncitizens engaged in the invasion under Section 212(f) of the Immigration and Nationality Act, according to SCOTUSblog. Guidance from the Department of Homeland Security then barred covered noncitizens from applying for asylum and provided for quick removal without some of the procedural protections in the statute.

The challenge was filed on February 3, 2025, by the Refugee and Immigrant Center for Education and Legal Services, known as RAICES, together with Las Americas Immigrant Advocacy Center and the Florence Immigrant and Refugee Rights Project, along with 13 individuals who say they faced persecution or torture in their home countries, according to SCOTUSblog. Federal law at 8 U.S.C. 1158(a)(1) allows a person who is physically present in the United States to apply for asylum, and that statutory text is the center of the dispute.

Two courts have already ruled against the administration. United States District Judge Randolph Moss ruled in July 2025 that the proclamation and guidance were unlawful in substantial part and entered class wide relief. A panel of the United States Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit largely affirmed in April 2026. Judge J. Michelle Childs, joined by Judge Cornelia Pillard, wrote that Congress did not intend to grant the Executive the expansive removal authority it asserts, according to SCOTUSblog's summary of the ruling. Judge Justin Walker dissented in part. The appeals court stayed its own mandate pending Supreme Court review, which is why the asylum shutdown has remained in force throughout the litigation.

The justices declined to take up the government's third question, which attacked whether the certified class of challengers complies with class action rules. The government's main brief is due in late December 2026 unless extended, and arguments are expected in spring 2027, according to SCOTUSblog.

BACKGROUND AND CONTEXT

Asylum is not a discretionary program created by executive order. Congress built it into the Immigration and Nationality Act, providing that people who reach the United States may apply for protection and have their claims heard, including claims based on persecution and torture. Presidents have wide authority over entry under Section 212(f), and the legal question is where that authority ends when a specific statute grants a specific right to apply.

This case also arrives as part of a crowded immigration docket. The Court decided a related metering dispute in June 2026, agreed in October to review mandatory detention without bond hearings, and has been asked to resolve multiple fights over removals and detention in this term alone, according to SCOTUSblog and PBS NewsHour reporting. The asylum case is the broadest of them because it asks whether the underlying right to seek protection can be switched off by proclamation at all.

WHY THIS MATTERS

For people fleeing persecution, the practical effect is immediate and it is happening now, not in June 2027. Because the policy stays in effect during the case, a person who reaches the southern border cannot apply for asylum, even though two courts have said the policy that blocks the application is illegal. Documented consequences include removals carried out under the guidance the lower courts struck down. Potential consequences reach further. If the Court sides with the administration, future presidents would hold a template for suspending other statutory protections by declaring an emergency at the border. If the Court sides with the challengers, the ruling would reaffirm that Congress, not the president, writes the asylum system.

The case also matters for households far from the border. A ruling that a proclamation can override a statute would shift power over immigration, and by extension over other programs Congress created, toward the White House in ways that outlast this administration and this issue.

THE POLITICAL PERSPECTIVE

The administration's position treats asylum as a benefit the president may grant or withhold. The statute treats it as a legal process Congress established for people who claim they will be persecuted or tortured, and the difference between those two descriptions is the whole case. The challengers argue in their brief that the president may not invent by fiat a new removal system that eviscerates the protections Congress mandated by statute, according to the brief in opposition filed in the case. That argument does not depend on sympathy for any individual claim. It depends on whether laws mean what they say when a president finds them inconvenient. Protecting that principle protects vulnerable people first, because they are the ones with no other forum when the legal process is closed to them.

THE OTHER SIDE

Solicitor General D. John Sauer argues in the government's petition that blocking entry and asylum access are the most important and effective pieces of the president's response at the border, and that asylum is a purely discretionary benefit, according to the petition in No. 26 239. The petition credits the proclamation with a 93 percent drop in border encounters. The challengers answer in their brief that border apprehensions had already returned to historically routine levels, down more than 90 percent from their peak, by January 2025, before the proclamation took effect, according to the brief in opposition. Both numbers cannot carry the causal weight the petition assigns to the policy, and readers should treat the administration's figure as a claim about correlation that the opposing brief directly disputes with the timeline.

Supporters of the policy also argue that the asylum system was abused and overwhelmed, and that a president facing a surge must be able to act quickly. That concern about capacity is a real policy argument. It does not by itself answer the statutory question the Court took, which is whether acting quickly required, or legally permitted, suspending the right to apply rather than funding and staffing the system Congress built.

WHAT HAPPENS NEXT

The government's opening brief is due in late December 2026 unless the Court extends the deadline. Arguments are expected in spring 2027, and a decision is expected by the end of the term in June 2027, according to SCOTUSblog. Until then, the restrictions remain in force. Watch for the December 28 briefing deadline, for any request to extend it, and for states and members of Congress filing supporting briefs on either side. A separate asylum related case on the docket, Wassily v. Blanche, is scheduled for argument on November 30, 2026, and its reasoning on asylum and permanent residence may signal how the justices are thinking about the statutory scheme before the Mullin arguments begin.

SOURCES AND DOCUMENTATION

Supreme Court of the United States, Order List, November 13, 2026, granting certiorari in No. 26 239 limited to Questions 1 and 2. Supports the grant, its scope, and the case number.

https://www.supremecourt.gov/orders/courtorders/111326zor_8n5a.pdf

SCOTUSblog, Supreme Court agrees to hear case on Trump administration's suspension of asylum at the southern border, November 2026. Supports the proclamation's terms, the parties, the lower court history, and the expected argument timing.

https://www.scotusblog.com/2026/11/supreme-court-agrees-to-hear-case-on-trump-administrations-suspension-of-asylum/

Supreme Court of the United States, Petition for a writ of certiorari in No. 26 239, filed by the Solicitor General. Supports the government's arguments and its 93 percent encounters claim.

https://www.supremecourt.gov/docket/26-239

Supreme Court of the United States, Brief in opposition in No. 26 239, filed by the challengers. Supports the counter timeline on border apprehensions and the statutory argument quoted above.

https://www.supremecourt.gov/docket/26-239

WorkersRights.News, Supreme Court takes up Trump's border asylum ban, a policy two courts called illegal, November 15, 2026.

https://www.workersrights.news/supreme-court-to-decide-trump-border-asylum-ban-invasion-proclamation/

Fact check note: The justices have agreed to hear the case. They have not ruled on whether the policy is lawful, and no argument date had been set as of November 15, 2026. Claims about the policy's effect on border encounters are disputed between the parties' briefs and are presented above as claims, not findings.

WEAR YOUR VOICE