ICE Officers Randomly Scanned License Plates at Oregon Stores. A Federal Judge Ruled the Arrest That Followed Was Unlawful

U.S. District Judge Mustafa Kasubhai found that officers had no valid warrant and no legal basis to detain a 56 year old Albany man who has lived in Oregon for 35 years, and he announced evidentiary hearings in every immigration detention challenge that reaches his court.

IMMIGRATION

11/22/20267 min read

Photo: Chris Phan via Wikimedia Commons (CC BY)

A federal judge in Eugene ruled on Friday, November 20, that U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement officers acted unlawfully when they arrested a 56 year old man outside a Walmart in Albany, Oregon, after testimony showed the officers were not looking for him or for anyone in particular. They were randomly scanning the license plates of shoppers in store parking lots (Seattle Focal, November 21, 2026, https://focalnews.org/portland-or/politics/federal-judge-rules-ice-arrest-of-albany-man-at-walmart-unlawful-calls-out-random-license-plate-scans). U.S. District Judge Mustafa T. Kasubhai found that the officers had no valid warrant and no legal justification for the stop, and he announced that he intends to hold an evidentiary hearing, with officers called to testify, in every habeas petition assigned to him that challenges an immigration detention.

The Details

The arrest happened on June 18 at about 10:30 a.m. The man, whose first language is a Mayan language and who testified through an interpreter, had just bought water and bread for his work crew and was walking back to his pickup truck when officers took him into custody (Seattle Focal, November 21, 2026). He has lived in Oregon for 35 years, having entered the United States in 1991 fleeing violence in Mexico, according to his lawyers. He runs a pallet repair business, employs three workers, has four children and pays taxes. He holds a work permit and has a pending immigration case, with a hearing scheduled for February at which he is challenging his removal (Seattle Focal, November 21, 2026).

At the hearing, testimony from at least half a dozen ICE officers established how he came to be arrested. A Portland based supervisor, identified in court as D.B., acknowledged that his team was not searching for any specific person designated for deportation. Instead, officers were randomly scanning license plates in the parking lots of Walmart, Safeway and Fred Meyer stores in Albany and Dallas, Oregon. On the morning of the arrest, D.B. texted his officers, "Let's hit Albany / Dallas," and sent the addresses of the two Walmart locations (Seattle Focal, November 21, 2026). Questioned by Stephen Manning, an attorney with the nonprofit Innovation Law Lab, D.B. denied that the cities were chosen because of their Latino and working class immigrant populations. Pressed by the judge on why Walmart lots were targeted, he said, "Walmart opens early. We usually start our shifts early," and added that officers run plates at grocery store lots because "we're looking to arrest people and that's where people are mobile" (Seattle Focal, November 21, 2026). Kasubhai noted that he had not heard of ICE conducting similar operations at Whole Foods Market or at Bridgeport Village, a high end shopping center.

On the warrant question, the judge found that officers never served the man with a valid warrant, never read one to him and never told him one existed. The government said officers held a digital copy, but there was no record of a date of service. Kasubhai ruled that the warrant was invalid on that record and that the arrest was independently improper as a warrantless arrest, because officers never evaluated whether the man posed an escape risk (Seattle Focal, November 21, 2026). He called the man the "most credible witness" who testified about that day and concluded, "The arrest itself is unlawful."

After the arrest, officers drove the man to the ICE facility in Portland, then toward Tacoma, then back to Portland, where they left him about 70 miles from his home. Kasubhai ordered ICE officers not to abandon people they release miles from home, and to return released detainees to their hometowns or to the vehicles they left behind (Seattle Focal, November 21, 2026). He said he will issue a written opinion in the case. He also announced the standing practice for his courtroom going forward: an evidentiary hearing in every habeas case assigned to him that challenges a detention, with federal officers called to testify. "I'll continue to do that until someone tells me I can't," he said (Seattle Focal, November 21, 2026).

Background and Context

Friday's ruling is the third time this year that Kasubhai has ruled against ICE's arrest practices in Oregon, and the earlier rulings supply the legal frame for this one. On February 4, 2026, in a class action brought by Innovation Law Lab, he issued a preliminary injunction barring ICE from making warrantless arrests in Oregon unless the person is likely to flee, and requiring documentation of those arrests; he explained the injunction in a written opinion on February 27. The government appealed to the Ninth Circuit on April 6, and that appeal is still pending (Lincoln Chronicle, November 2026, https://lincolnchronicle.org/this-is-sloppy-work-federal-judge-finds-ice-officer-lied-in-oregon-arrest-report-says-agency-violated-his-order/).

On November 2, in a 50 page opinion in the same class action, Kasubhai found that ICE had continued making warrantless arrests without the individualized escape risk findings his February order requires, and that the agency's paperwork could no longer be taken at face value. He found that one deportation officer, identified as J.G., lied in an official arrest report, a Form I-213, to make a warrantless arrest appear warrant based, writing, "The court finds that he did not make a mistake in the I-213. He lied in an official record to facilitate the impression he was conducting a lawful warrant-based arrest." He also found that ICE conducted significantly more warrantless arrests between February and August than the 13 the government had reported, and he ordered the government to turn over all arrest documents to Innovation Law Lab and body camera footage for arrests conducted on or after September 1, 2026 (Lincoln Chronicle, November 2026). Court data presented at a September evidentiary hearing put ICE's Oregon arrests between February 5 and July 31 at 574, of which 504 were noncustodial arrests made in the community rather than at a jail (summary of the November 2 opinion, November 2026).

Whether the officers' actions in the Albany case were racially motivated will be considered as part of that separate class action, in which Kasubhai has already ordered ICE officers in Oregon to stop making warrantless arrests. "It's not lost on me what and how ICE is targeting certain communities, neighborhoods with a very identifiable Latino community," he said on Friday (Seattle Focal, November 21, 2026).

Why This Matters

A random plate scan in a grocery store parking lot does not distinguish between the person officers are looking for and everyone else in the lot, because on the supervisor's own testimony there was no person they were looking for. Every shopper's plate was run, by an officer's account, with no rhyme or reason, until a name produced a reason to make an arrest. That method puts the entire burden of a federal enforcement program on whichever communities shop at the stores officers choose to work, and the judge's observation about which stores were chosen, and which were not, is now part of a court record. For the man at the center of the case, the consequences were concrete: an arrest the court has ruled unlawful, a drive of hundreds of miles in custody, and a release 70 miles from home, all while holding a work permit and an open immigration case. The standing hearing requirement matters just as much. It means that in this court, the government will have to prove the lawfulness of a detention with witnesses, case by case, rather than rest on its own forms, forms this same judge found three weeks ago to contain at least one deliberate fabrication.

The Political Perspective

The constitutional problem with the Albany operation is not subtle, and it does not depend on anyone's view of immigration policy. Enforcement that begins with no target, no warrant that is ever shown to the person arrested, and no assessment of flight risk is enforcement that treats presence in a parking lot as probable cause. The people exposed to it are not abstractions. They are workers buying supplies for a job, parents in a grocery lot, a man who has paid taxes in Oregon for 35 years and employs three other people. Courts are often described as a backstop in this system. In Oregon this year they have been something more active: the only institution that has made ICE explain, under oath and on the record, how its arrests actually happen. Friday's ruling is what that explanation produced.

The Other Side

The government's defense at the hearing was narrower than a claim that the operation was well designed. Its position was that officers held a digital copy of a warrant for the man, and its witnesses offered an operational explanation for the parking lot sweeps: officers work grocery store lots early because the stores open early and because that is where people are mobile (Seattle Focal, November 21, 2026). The supervisor denied that Albany and Dallas were selected because of their Latino and working class immigrant populations. Kasubhai considered those explanations and rejected the warrant defense on the record before him, finding no evidence the warrant was ever served, read or disclosed, and finding the Albany man more credible than the officers on the events of the day. No separate public statement by ICE on Friday's ruling was reported in the coverage consulted for this article.

What Happens Next

Kasubhai said he will issue a written opinion in the Albany case, which will set out the ruling's reasoning in full (Seattle Focal, November 21, 2026). The racial motivation question raised by the parking lot selection will be taken up in the Innovation Law Lab class action, where the February injunction against warrantless arrests already stands and where the November 2 enforcement order requires ICE to hand over arrest records and body camera footage. The government's appeal of the February injunction remains pending at the Ninth Circuit. And in Kasubhai's courtroom, every new habeas petition challenging an immigration detention will now get an evidentiary hearing with officers on the stand, a commitment he stated on the record on Friday.

Sources and Documentation

- Seattle Focal, "Federal Judge Rules ICE Arrest of Albany Man at Walmart Unlawful, Calls Out Random License Plate Scans," November 21, 2026. https://focalnews.org/portland-or/politics/federal-judge-rules-ice-arrest-of-albany-man-at-walmart-unlawful-calls-out-random-license-plate-scans Supports the ruling, the random plate scan testimony and the supervisor's text message and explanations, the man's history and circumstances, the warrant findings, the transport and release facts, the order against abandoning released detainees, and the announcement of hearings in every habeas case.

- Lincoln Chronicle, "'This is sloppy work': Federal judge finds ICE officer lied in Oregon arrest report, says agency violated his order," November 2026. https://lincolnchronicle.org/this-is-sloppy-work-federal-judge-finds-ice-officer-lied-in-oregon-arrest-report-says-agency-violated-his-order/ Supports the November 2 enforcement opinion, the finding that an officer lied in a Form I-213, the disclosure and body camera orders, the February injunction's terms, and the government's undercount of warrantless arrests.

- Case history summary of M-J-M-A v. Hernandez (D. Or.), including the February 4, 2026 preliminary injunction, the February 27 written opinion and the April 6, 2026 notice of appeal to the Ninth Circuit, November 2026. https://www.567politics.com/news/oregon-ice-warrantless-arrests-kasubhai-order-violation-november-2026 Supports the class action timeline and the pending appeal.

Fact-check note: Friday's ruling was delivered from the bench and the written opinion has not yet been issued, so quotations and findings are drawn from contemporaneous reporting of the hearing. The Albany man is not named in the reporting consulted; court coverage of the related class action identifies a June 18 Walmart arrestee by initials only. ICE had not been reported to have issued a separate statement on this ruling as of publication.

WEAR YOUR VOICE