HUD Tried to Steer $1.3 Billion Away From Permanent Housing. A Federal Judge Said No
U.S. District Judge Mary McElroy ruled on Friday that the Department of Housing and Urban Development exceeded its authority when it tried to remake the $4 billion Continuum of Care program, and she ordered the agency to reopen grant applications through December 1.
ECONOMY
11/21/20264 min read


Photo: Викидим via Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0)
A federal judge in Rhode Island ruled on Friday, November 20, that the Trump administration acted unlawfully when it tried to overhaul the nation's main homelessness program, steering money away from permanent housing and toward temporary housing and services (Reuters, November 20, 2026, https://www.reuters.com/legal/government/us-judge-rejects-trump-administrations-homelessness-program-revamp-2026-11-20/). U.S. District Judge Mary McElroy found that the Department of Housing and Urban Development had exceeded the authority Congress gave it, and she blocked the new funding plan for the Continuum of Care program, which distributes more than $4 billion a year.
THE DETAILS
The fight centered on HUD's plan to set aside $1.3 billion of the more than $4 billion Congress appropriated for fiscal year 2026 for transitional housing and supportive service only grants, rather than permanent housing (Reuters, November 20, 2026). McElroy held that HUD had added award criteria that effectively let the agency bypass what the McKinney Vento Homeless Assistance Act requires, including evaluating existing projects on their performance and moving people into permanent housing.
"Although Congress delegated to the secretary the power to create additional criteria for awarding funds, this residual clause cannot be read as allowing HUD to nullify the other congressionally established mandatory factors," she wrote (Reuters, November 20, 2026).
The judge also struck down other parts of the plan, including a restriction on grant recipients engaging in activities aimed at drug users, such as needle exchanges, and a provision that would have let the agency disqualify applicants that did not adequately promote "self-sufficiency" (Reuters, November 20, 2026). She ordered HUD to let applicants amend and resubmit their grant applications through December 1 and to make funding awards by December 31.
BACKGROUND AND CONTEXT
The Continuum of Care program has operated since 1987, providing money to states, local governments and nonprofits that serve people experiencing homelessness, with a focus on veterans, families and people with disabilities (Reuters, November 20, 2026). It has traditionally followed a housing first model, which prioritizes placing people in permanent housing without preconditions such as sobriety or employment, and its grants also pay for services including childcare, job training, mental health counseling and transportation.
The Trump administration has criticized that model and has tried repeatedly to redirect the money. McElroy blocked an earlier version of the changes in 2025 and again earlier this year, only for a federal appeals court to lift the second order (Reuters, November 20, 2026). After that appellate ruling, 22 mostly Democratic led states, the District of Columbia and a coalition of housing and homelessness organizations, including the National Alliance to End Homelessness, renewed their challenge on different legal grounds, and Friday's ruling answered that renewed case. McElroy herself was appointed to the bench by President Trump after first being nominated by President Barack Obama (Reuters, November 20, 2026).
WHY THIS MATTERS
Continuum of Care money is the financial backbone of local homelessness systems across the country. When its rules change midstream, the organizations that run shelters, outreach teams and permanent supportive housing cannot plan, and the people who feel it first are the ones sleeping outside or in their cars. The administration's plan would have moved $1.3 billion in a single year away from the permanent housing placements that the statute instructs HUD to reward, and toward temporary arrangements that end. Friday's ruling does not settle the policy argument about housing first. It settles a prior question: whether an agency may rewrite a statute's priorities on its own. On the record before her, the judge said it may not, and the December deadlines she imposed now govern whether this year's funding reaches communities on schedule.
THE POLITICAL PERSPECTIVE
The pattern in this case is familiar. Congress wrote a law with mandatory factors. The executive branch, unable to persuade Congress to change them, tried to accomplish the same result through grant criteria. That is not a technicality. The power to decide what federal money rewards is the power to set national policy, and the Constitution assigns that power to the legislature. It matters most exactly where it mattered here, in a program for people with no lobby and no margin for delay. A ruling that forces the administration to go back to Congress is a ruling that keeps housing policy answerable to voters.
THE OTHER SIDE
HUD Secretary Scott Turner criticized the decision, saying it "disrupts $4 billion for our most vulnerable, just days before funding awards were set to be made" (Reuters, November 20, 2026, syndicated report). The administration's underlying argument is that the housing first model has failed on its own terms, that homelessness has remained high despite years of spending, and that funding should reward transitional housing and services that push people toward self sufficiency. Those are arguments about policy outcomes, and Congress is free to act on them. The court's holding was narrower: whatever the merits of the new approach, HUD could not adopt it by adding criteria that nullified the factors Congress had already made mandatory.
WHAT HAPPENS NEXT
The deadlines are immediate. Applicants have through December 1 to amend and resubmit their grant applications, and HUD must make funding awards by December 31 (Reuters, November 20, 2026). The administration can appeal, as it did after McElroy's earlier rulings in this dispute, and an appeals court lifted one of her previous orders. Nothing in Friday's ruling prevents the administration from asking Congress to amend the McKinney Vento Act itself.
SOURCES AND DOCUMENTATION
- Reuters, "US judge rejects Trump administration's homelessness program revamp," November 20, 2026. https://www.reuters.com/legal/government/us-judge-rejects-trump-administrations-homelessness-program-revamp-2026-11-20/ Supports the holding, the $1.3 billion set aside, the McKinney Vento reasoning and quotation, the provisions struck down, the December deadlines, the history of the litigation, and Secretary Turner's response.
Fact-check note: This is the third ruling by the same judge against versions of the same policy, and one earlier order was lifted on appeal. Friday's decision is a district court ruling on the renewed challenge, not the final word in the case, and this article describes it that way.
WEAR YOUR VOICE
Follow


Privacy Policy · Terms and Conditions · Refund Policy · Shipping Info
© 2025 My Voice Ofc. All rights reserved.
