Jacksonville Judges Grant 47 Habeas Petitions Against ICE

Jacksonville federal judges granted at least 47 habeas petitions by immigration detainees in three weeks, ordering individualized bond hearings or release and rejecting blanket detention under the wrong statute.

IMMIGRATION

11/14/20267 min read

Photo: Joe Gratz via Wikimedia Commons (CC0)

In three weeks, in one federal courthouse in Jacksonville, Florida, judges granted at least 47 habeas corpus petitions brought by people held in immigration detention. In most of those cases the government was given seven days to hold an individualized bond hearing or release the person. The orders were counted by the First Coast Ledger from the public list of opinions and orders issued by the Jacksonville Division of the United States District Court for the Middle District of Florida from October 23 through November 12, 2026. That number matters because each petition represents a person who was locked up and who, under the government position in these cases, was not entitled to ask a judge to consider bond at all. The Jacksonville judges said otherwise, again and again, following binding precedent from the United States Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit. (First Coast Ledger)

The latest verified information in this report is as of November 14, 2026. Most of the cases involve people held at ICE detention sites in Baker County, often identified on the docket as the North Florida Detention Facility. At least five involve the Flagler County Jail. (First Coast Ledger)

The Details

A habeas corpus petition is a request to a federal court to decide whether the government is holding someone lawfully. In the Jacksonville cases, detainees asked the court to order either their release or an individualized bond hearing under Section 1226(a) of the Immigration and Nationality Act, codified at 8 U.S.C. Section 1226(a). The Ledger count found at least 47 grants in the three-week window. (First Coast Ledger)

Chief Judge Marcia Morales Howard signed the largest share, about 20 of the orders. Judge Wendy W. Berger and Judge Jordan Emery Pratt signed about 13 each. Senior Judge Timothy J. Corrigan, who preceded Howard as chief judge, signed at least one. (First Coast Ledger)

One case shows how far the government went. On October 27, Chief Judge Howard ordered the federal government to release Victoriia Tsarionova within 24 hours. Federal lawyers had told the court that Tsarionova was detained under Section 1226(a), a statute that generally allows an immigration judge to consider bond, and they conceded that under a 2026 Eleventh Circuit decision she was entitled to an individualized bond hearing. ICE then transferred her to Texas. Texas sits in the Fifth Circuit, which has held in Buenrostro Mendez v. Bondi, 166 F.4th 494, that people in her position are not entitled to those hearings. Howard ordered her released within a day anyway. (First Coast Ledger)

The next day, Judge Pratt granted a petition filed by Ricardo Eire, a Cuban citizen who entered the United States in 1971, according to the Ledger account of the order. (First Coast Ledger)

The individual court orders tell the same story in the same language. In case after case, the Jacksonville court granted the petition on the claim that detention without an individualized bond hearing violates the Immigration and Nationality Act, and ordered respondents, within seven days, to either afford the petitioner an individualized bond hearing consistent with Section 1226(a) or release the petitioner. Those orders are public records on the court docket system for the Middle District of Florida. (First Coast Ledger; U.S. District Court, Middle District of Florida)

Background and Context

The legal fight is over which part of federal immigration law applies when the government detains someone who is already in the country. One provision, Section 1225, is the rule for many people arriving at the border and seeking admission. Another provision, Section 1226(a), covers many people already inside the United States who are in removal proceedings, and it provides for individualized bond consideration. (First Coast Ledger)

In Hernandez Alvarez v. Warden, Federal Detention Center Miami, decided May 6, 2026, the Eleventh Circuit addressed that divide. The Jacksonville orders quote the decision as concluding that Section 1225 applies to arriving aliens seeking entry at the border, whereas Section 1226 applies to aliens unlawfully in the interior. Because Florida is in the Eleventh Circuit, that reading binds the Jacksonville judges. (First Coast Ledger)

The practical stakes are concrete. Detention separates parents from children, workers from jobs, and patients from care, and it does so before any final decision about whether a person will be removed. A bond hearing does not decide the immigration case. It decides a narrower and more basic question: whether this particular person, on this particular record, needs to be locked up while the case proceeds, or whether conditions such as bond can reasonably manage any flight risk or danger the government can actually show. (First Coast Ledger)

Why This Matters

At least 47 people held in immigration detention in the Jacksonville area won court orders in three weeks requiring the government to give them an individualized bond hearing or release them. The judges found that the government was detaining people under the wrong statute and denying them a hearing the law requires. For working families, a bond hearing is the difference between a household that keeps functioning and one that loses its income, its housing, and its stability in a matter of days. For local communities in Baker County, Flagler County, and Jacksonville, it is also the difference between a detention system that answers to a judge and one that answers to no one. (First Coast Ledger)

The Political Perspective

The government position tested in these cases would have treated a large category of people already living in the United States as if they had just arrived at the border, and would have denied them individualized bond hearings on that basis. The Eleventh Circuit rejected that reading, and the Jacksonville judges applied the binding precedent in front of them. That is not activism described accurately; it is a district court following the court of appeals that governs it. (First Coast Ledger)

Detention separates parents from children, workers from jobs, and patients from care, and it does so before any final decision about whether a person will be removed. A bond hearing does not decide the immigration case. It decides whether this particular person needs to be locked up while the case proceeds, or whether bond can reasonably manage any flight risk or danger the government can actually show. For working families, that distinction is the difference between a household that keeps functioning and one that loses its income, its housing, and its stability in a matter of days. (First Coast Ledger)

The Tsarionova transfer deserves separate scrutiny. After federal lawyers conceded she was entitled to a bond hearing under Eleventh Circuit law, ICE moved her to a state inside a circuit that has ruled the other way. Moving a detainee is sometimes routine. Moving a detainee after a concession like that, to the one region where the concession would no longer help her, raises a question the government should have to answer in public: was the transfer about logistics, or was it about changing the law that applied to her by changing her location? Chief Judge Howard answered the immediate question by ordering release within 24 hours. The broader question about transfer practices remains open. (First Coast Ledger)

The Other Side

The government's position in these cases was that the detainees were not entitled to individualized bond hearings, because it treated them as arriving aliens subject to Section 1225 rather than as people already in the interior subject to Section 1226(a). The Eleventh Circuit rejected that reading, and the Jacksonville judges applied the binding precedent. (First Coast Ledger)

It is also important to state what these orders do not do. They do not grant anyone permanent legal status. They do not end removal proceedings. They do not guarantee that bond will be granted in any individual case. A petitioner can receive a hearing and still be detained if the government meets its burden there. What the orders guarantee is the hearing itself: an individualized decision, by a neutral decision maker, based on evidence about that person. (First Coast Ledger)

On the Tsarionova transfer, it is unconfirmed, on the public record reviewed for this article, why that specific transfer was made. Moving a detainee is sometimes routine, and the government has not publicly explained this one. The question remains open, and this article does not present speculation about it as fact. (First Coast Ledger)

What Happens Next

Watch three things. First, whether the government complies with the seven-day deadlines in each granted case by holding real individualized hearings, rather than treating the orders as paperwork. Second, whether detainees who win hearings actually receive bond decisions that reflect their individual circumstances, including length of residence, family ties, and record. Third, whether the conflict between circuits, illustrated by the Fifth Circuit ruling in Buenrostro Mendez and the Eleventh Circuit ruling in Hernandez Alvarez, is taken up at a national level, because a person's liberty currently depends in part on which side of a circuit line ICE chooses to hold them. (First Coast Ledger)

For families with a loved one held in Baker County or Flagler County, the Jacksonville orders also carry a practical lesson that lawyers in the district have repeated in these filings: federal habeas review is a real and available check, and in this three-week window it succeeded at least 47 times. (First Coast Ledger)

SOURCES

First Coast Ledger, "Jacksonville Judges Grant 47 Habeas Petitions Against ICE in 3 Weeks" — Supports the count of at least 47 grants, the judges and their shares, the Tsarionova and Eire cases, the Eleventh Circuit precedent, and the seven-day bond-hearing-or-release orders.

https://www.firstcoastledger.com/jacksonville-judges-grant-47-habeas-petitions-against-ice/

United States District Court, Middle District of Florida, Jacksonville Division order, Case No. 3:26 cv 394 — Supports the court order in one of the habeas cases.

https://ecf.flmd.uscourts.gov/cgi-bin/show_public_doc?2026-00394-10-3-cv

United States District Court, Middle District of Florida, Jacksonville Division order, Case No. 3:26 cv 1319 — Supports the court order in one of the habeas cases.

https://ecf.flmd.uscourts.gov/cgi-bin/show_public_doc?2026-01319-6-3-cv

United States District Court, Middle District of Florida, History of Jacksonville Courthouse — Background on the Jacksonville courthouse.

https://www.flmd.uscourts.gov/node/434

Fact-check note: This is a developing court story. The count of at least 47 grants covers October 23 through November 12, 2026, as counted by the First Coast Ledger from the court's public list of opinions and orders. The orders require an individualized bond hearing or release within seven days; whether the government complies, and whether it appeals, had not been reported as of November 14, 2026. The reason for the transfer of Victoriia Tsarionova to Texas is unconfirmed on the public record reviewed for this article. The orders do not grant permanent legal status, do not end removal proceedings, and do not guarantee bond in any individual case.

WEAR YOUR VOICE