ICE Agents Pepper Sprayed and Took a Pregnant U.S. Citizen to the Ground in Modesto. She Was Released Without Charges
Lizbeth Vargas Andrade, a 23 year old U.S. citizen from Ceres who is 12 weeks pregnant, went to the Stanislaus County jail on Sunday as a volunteer monitoring immigration enforcement. She left in handcuffs, was driven to a detention office in Stockton and was held for about five hours before being released without a single charge. ICE says she obstructed an arrest. She says she never touched an agent. Tonight, her community gets its say at a town hall in south Modesto.
IMMIGRATION
11/18/202610 min read


Photo: U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) / Public domain
Lizbeth Vargas Andrade was standing in the parking lot of the Stanislaus County jail in Modesto on Sunday afternoon, livestreaming immigration agents as part of a volunteer network that alerts residents to enforcement activity, when agents took her to the ground on her stomach, handcuffed her and pepper sprayed her. She is a U.S. citizen. She is 12 weeks pregnant. After about five hours in federal custody and a hospital evaluation that found her baby unharmed, she was released without criminal or immigration charges, according to her attorney (The Modesto Focus: https://themodestofocus.org/modesto-town-hall-set-as-outrage-spreads-over-ice-agents-pepper-spraying-detaining-pregnant-u-s-citizen/).
"Being pregnant, my first thought was my baby, my kids. What was going to happen?" the 23 year old mother of two said at a press conference on Monday (The Modesto Focus: https://themodestofocus.org/modesto-town-hall-set-as-outrage-spreads-over-ice-agents-pepper-spraying-detaining-pregnant-u-s-citizen/).
The Details
The encounter began at about noon on Sunday, November 15. Vargas Andrade said she was parked in the jail lot, watching ICE vehicles as part of the volunteer monitoring network. Her husband's sister, Monica Alvarado, offered a ride to a man who was walking out of the jail. As Alvarado drove off, about five ICE agents pulled her vehicle over, and Vargas Andrade said the agents forced their way into the vehicle to pull the man out and take him into custody. She said no warrant or deportation order was shown during the interaction (The Modesto Focus: https://themodestofocus.org/modesto-town-hall-set-as-outrage-spreads-over-ice-agents-pepper-spraying-detaining-pregnant-u-s-citizen/).
Vargas Andrade and her husband, Adolfo Talavera Alvarado, approached the vehicle and began arguing with the agents. During the confrontation, an agent alleged that Vargas Andrade slapped him. She denies assaulting any officer. She says she told the agent, "I'm pregnant, so don't put your hands on me," before agents moved in (The Modesto Focus: https://themodestofocus.org/modesto-town-hall-set-as-outrage-spreads-over-ice-agents-pepper-spraying-detaining-pregnant-u-s-citizen/).
Video recorded by her husband shows what happened next. Agents took Vargas Andrade to the ground, where she landed on her stomach, and handcuffed her as bystanders and her husband shouted that she was pregnant. An agent deployed pepper spray toward her and her husband. In her own words: "They threw me to the ground, they maced me, then they handcuffed me" (The States Journal: https://thestatesjournal.com/articles/ice-agents-pepper-spray-pregnant-u-s-citizen-outside-modesto-jail-78d75683/).
Agents drove her roughly 50 minutes away to the ICE Enforcement and Removal Operations office in Stockton. She said that despite repeatedly telling officials she was pregnant, she was held without medical care for more than two hours, and that she was not permitted to speak with her family or with Modesto attorney Harlan Diven, who was at the scene. Her younger sister, Valeria Vargas, eventually called an ambulance for her. Paramedics found her blood sugar and blood pressure elevated and took her to San Joaquin General Hospital, where an ultrasound found no harm to her pregnancy and doctors cleared her. Her family says her pregnancy is considered high risk because of her Type 2 diabetes, and that she has previously suffered two pregnancy losses (The Modesto Focus: https://themodestofocus.org/modesto-town-hall-set-as-outrage-spreads-over-ice-agents-pepper-spraying-detaining-pregnant-u-s-citizen/).
After about five hours in custody, she was released without charges.
On Monday, Vargas Andrade and her attorney, Patrick Kolasinski, held a press conference in the same jail parking lot. In a written statement, Kolasinski said multiple videos of the incident contradict the agents' claim that she assaulted them, and he called for a thorough and transparent examination of the detention, the force used against her and her treatment in custody. "ICE is not supposed to be detaining U.S. citizens," Kolasinski said. "They're not gods. If they're law enforcement, they should enforce and follow the law. It's that simple" (The Modesto Focus: https://themodestofocus.org/modesto-town-hall-set-as-outrage-spreads-over-ice-agents-pepper-spraying-detaining-pregnant-u-s-citizen/). He said the family is exploring a civil lawsuit.
On Tuesday, ICE gave its account. The agency said its agents were arresting Fabian Santiago Martinez, a Mexican national who, according to ICE, entered the country illegally, had been charged with multiple DUIs and had accepted voluntary return to Mexico. Of Vargas Andrade, the statement said she "actively interfered with, obstructed, and attempted to prevent the arrest," which the agency called a federal crime, and that its officer "relied on his training to safely control the situation despite the combative, aggressive, and heinously vulgar conduct of the woman interfering with his lawful duties." ICE said she immediately received medical care and was taken to San Joaquin General Hospital for evaluation, a timeline her account disputes (ABC News: https://newstalk1290koil.com/2026/11/16/ice-agents-accused-of-throwing-pregnant-us-citizen-to-ground-pepper-spraying-her/; QNC News: https://qncnews.com/2026/11/18/pregnant-us-citizen-pepper-sprayed-and-detained-by-ice-in-modesto/).
The Stanislaus County Sheriff's Office, which runs the jail, confirmed the confrontation happened in its parking lot and said its deputies took no part in the arrest. A Justice Department spokesperson declined to comment, and no charging decision has been announced (The States Journal: https://thestatesjournal.com/articles/ice-agents-pepper-spray-pregnant-u-s-citizen-outside-modesto-jail-78d75683/).
Background and Context
Immigration agents have no authority to deport a U.S. citizen, and citizens are not subject to immigration detention. When citizens are arrested at enforcement operations, the legal basis federal officials cite is almost always a criminal allegation, most often that the person assaulted or obstructed an agent. That allegation is the center of this case, and it is disputed.
Vargas Andrade's case is not an isolated one. A ProPublica investigation published on October 6, 2026 documented 506 U.S. citizens detained by immigration agents between January 2025 and September 2026, and described its own count as an undercount. More than 300 of those citizens were detained after agents accused them of assaulting, obstructing or interfering with officers. Federal criminal charges were filed in only 137 of the cases ProPublica reviewed, and nearly half of those charged saw their cases dropped or dismissed. At least 63 citizens were detained while recording agents. The federal government does not publish its own count of citizen detentions. The Department of Homeland Security told ProPublica that its enforcement operations are "highly targeted" (ProPublica investigation, summarized by VisaVerge: https://www.visaverge.com/immigration/506-us-citizens-detained-under-trump-crackdown-including-70-children/).
DHS and the Justice Department have repeatedly accused protesters of assaulting immigration agents in cases across California, and many of those prosecutions have collapsed in federal court (The States Journal: https://thestatesjournal.com/articles/ice-agents-pepper-spray-pregnant-u-s-citizen-outside-modesto-jail-78d75683/).
Sunday's confrontation is also the second time this year that ICE's conduct in Stanislaus County has drawn national attention. In April, ICE officers shot Carlos Ivan Mendoza Hernandez, 36, during a traffic stop near Interstate 5 in Patterson. Agents said he tried to run over an officer and was wanted for questioning in a homicide in El Salvador. Mendoza Hernandez, who is also represented by Kolasinski, denies both claims, and Salvadoran records show he was acquitted in that case in 2019. He remains in ICE custody (The Modesto Focus: https://themodestofocus.org/modesto-town-hall-set-as-outrage-spreads-over-ice-agents-pepper-spraying-detaining-pregnant-u-s-citizen/).
Local officials are also under scrutiny. California's SB 54 generally bars state and local law enforcement from using resources for federal immigration enforcement, and Sheriff Jeff Dirkse has said his department does not cooperate with ICE. The Modesto Police Department restated that position on Monday. But residents have circulated video of deputies and ICE officers talking cordially outside sheriff's headquarters, and Kolasinski has demanded that the sheriff and local elected officials disclose the nature and extent of any assistance deputies have given ICE (The Modesto Focus: https://themodestofocus.org/modesto-town-hall-set-as-outrage-spreads-over-ice-agents-pepper-spraying-detaining-pregnant-u-s-citizen/).
Why This Matters
The right to stand in a public place, record federal agents and object to what they are doing is not a technicality. It is the main way communities in the Central Valley and across the country learn what immigration enforcement actually looks like on the ground. Vargas Andrade was doing exactly that, as part of a volunteer network, when she ended up face down on the pavement.
The stakes of the encounter were not abstract. She was 12 weeks into a pregnancy her family describes as high risk, with a history of two losses. She says she announced her pregnancy before force was used, and the video shows her husband shouting it as she was taken down. She then spent hours in a detention office, by her account without medical care, until her sister summoned paramedics herself.
The accountability gap is the other half of the story. ICE's statement describes a federal crime committed by a combative woman. The outcome of the case is a citizen released the same day with no charges at all. When an agency's public description of an event and the legal result of that event diverge this sharply, residents are entitled to ask which one is accurate, and that question is now being asked of every level of government in Stanislaus County, from the sheriff to the county board to the area's member of Congress.
The Political Perspective
There is a pattern in the ProPublica numbers that this case fits precisely. Accusations of assault and obstruction account for the largest single category of citizen detentions, yet fewer than half of the citizens detained on those claims were ever charged, and nearly half of the charges that were filed collapsed. In case after case, the accusation does the work at the scene. It justifies the force, it fills the press statement, and then, very often, it is never tested in front of a judge.
Vargas Andrade's case followed that script to the letter. She was accused of slapping an agent, an allegation her attorney says the videos contradict. She was described by her own government as combative, aggressive and heinously vulgar. And she was released without a single charge, criminal or immigration, after five hours. If the government's account were solid, a charge would be the simplest thing in the world to file. None has been announced.
The political response in Stanislaus County has come from the local level. Supervisor Channce Condit, whose district includes south Modesto and Ceres, organized tonight's town hall and said he is "absolutely" concerned about increased ICE activity in the Valley. "We all should be," he said. Modesto Councilmember Chris Ricci criticized the sheriff's office for allowing ICE to operate from its parking lot and said federal officers are "violating people's constitutional rights, and that's what we're seeing over and over again with these guys" (The Modesto Focus: https://themodestofocus.org/modesto-town-hall-set-as-outrage-spreads-over-ice-agents-pepper-spraying-detaining-pregnant-u-s-citizen/).
For the immigrant communities of the Central Valley, and for the citizens who stand alongside them, the message of Sunday's video is chilling whether or not it was intended: monitor an arrest, and you may be treated as a criminal yourself. Vargas Andrade says she will keep showing up anyway. "We're not going to stop helping the community, even though this happened," she said. "We want our immigrant neighbors to feel safe here, even if there's all this going on" (The Modesto Focus: https://themodestofocus.org/modesto-town-hall-set-as-outrage-spreads-over-ice-agents-pepper-spraying-detaining-pregnant-u-s-citizen/).
The Other Side
ICE's position is that its agents were carrying out a lawful arrest of a man the agency describes as a Mexican national who entered the country illegally, faced multiple DUI charges and had agreed to return to Mexico voluntarily, and that Vargas Andrade inserted herself into that arrest. Obstructing a federal officer during an arrest is a federal crime, and ICE says its officers are trained to use the minimum amount of force necessary to resolve dangerous situations and to protect the public and themselves. The agency says its officer relied on his training to control the situation, and that Vargas Andrade immediately received medical care and hospital evaluation (ABC News: https://newstalk1290koil.com/2026/11/16/ice-agents-accused-of-throwing-pregnant-us-citizen-to-ground-pepper-spraying-her/).
The sheriff's office maintains that the incident is a federal matter in which its deputies played no role, and Board of Supervisors Chairman Vito Chiesa expressed confidence in the department, saying, "The sheriff has made it abundantly clear that he's not cooperating with ICE" (The Modesto Focus: https://themodestofocus.org/modesto-town-hall-set-as-outrage-spreads-over-ice-agents-pepper-spraying-detaining-pregnant-u-s-citizen/).
Modesto Councilmember Nick Bavaro declined to criticize the arrest itself, while affirming the right to protest. People have the right to protest, he said, "as long as they aren't interfering with law enforcement activities," adding that if ICE agents violated any laws, they should be held accountable (The Modesto Focus: https://themodestofocus.org/modesto-town-hall-set-as-outrage-spreads-over-ice-agents-pepper-spraying-detaining-pregnant-u-s-citizen/).
What Happens Next
The immediate next step is tonight. Stanislaus County officials will hold a community town hall on immigration enforcement this evening, Wednesday, November 18, at 6:30 p.m. at the Salvation Army Community Center, 1649 Las Vegas St. in south Modesto. Kolasinski is among the featured speakers, alongside prominent area immigration attorneys, Sheriff Jeff Dirkse and staff from the office of U.S. Rep. Adam Gray (The Modesto Focus: https://themodestofocus.org/modesto-town-hall-set-as-outrage-spreads-over-ice-agents-pepper-spraying-detaining-pregnant-u-s-citizen/).
Beyond tonight, three questions remain open. The family is exploring a civil lawsuit over the force used and her treatment in custody, according to Kolasinski. Federal prosecutors have announced no charging decision, and the Justice Department has declined to comment, which means the obstruction allegation ICE made on Tuesday could still, in principle, be filed or quietly dropped. And Kolasinski's demand that the sheriff disclose the full extent of any local assistance to ICE remains unanswered heading into the town hall.
Vargas Andrade also says she does not know what became of the man whose detention started all of this. ICE says Fabian Santiago Martinez accepted voluntary return to Mexico. "He thanked me for doing what we're doing," she said of the man she watched being taken away. "We're still worried about him as a community, because he didn't make it back to his family" (The Modesto Focus: https://themodestofocus.org/modesto-town-hall-set-as-outrage-spreads-over-ice-agents-pepper-spraying-detaining-pregnant-u-s-citizen/).
Sources
The Modesto Focus, "Modesto town hall set as outrage spreads over ICE agents pepper spraying, detaining pregnant U.S. citizen," November 17, 2026. The primary local reporting: the timeline of Sunday's encounter, Vargas Andrade's account and quotations, her treatment in custody, the reactions of county and city officials, the April Patterson shooting, and the town hall details. https://themodestofocus.org/modesto-town-hall-set-as-outrage-spreads-over-ice-agents-pepper-spraying-detaining-pregnant-u-s-citizen/
ABC News, "ICE agents accused of throwing pregnant US citizen to ground, pepper spraying her," November 16 to 17, 2026, republished by News Talk 1290 KOIL. Supports the text of ICE's Tuesday statement, including the obstruction allegation and the description of her conduct, and the video account of her husband shouting that she was pregnant. https://newstalk1290koil.com/2026/11/16/ice-agents-accused-of-throwing-pregnant-us-citizen-to-ground-pepper-spraying-her/
The States Journal, "ICE agents pepper spray pregnant U.S. citizen outside Modesto jail," November 18, 2026. Supports the ICE statement, the Justice Department's refusal to comment, the absence of any announced charging decision, the limits of what the video shows, and the record of California prosecutions of protesters collapsing in federal court. https://thestatesjournal.com/articles/ice-agents-pepper-spray-pregnant-u-s-citizen-outside-modesto-jail-78d75683/
QNC News, "Pregnant US Citizen Pepper Sprayed and Detained by ICE in Modesto," November 18, 2026. Supports ICE's identification of the man arrested on Sunday, his DUI charges and voluntary return, and the agency's statement that Vargas Andrade received medical care. https://qncnews.com/2026/11/18/pregnant-us-citizen-pepper-sprayed-and-detained-by-ice-in-modesto/
ProPublica, investigation into U.S. citizens detained by immigration agents, October 6, 2026, summarized by VisaVerge, "ProPublica: 506 U.S. Citizens Detained by ICE Agents," October 2026. Supports the count of 506 citizens detained between January 2025 and September 2026, the predominance of assault and obstruction accusations, the number of cases charged and dismissed, and DHS's response that its operations are highly targeted. https://www.visaverge.com/immigration/506-us-citizens-detained-under-trump-crackdown-including-70-children/
Fact-Check Note
The central facts of this encounter are disputed, and this article presents both accounts as their makers stated them. Vargas Andrade denies touching an agent and says she received no medical care for more than two hours in custody until her sister called an ambulance. ICE says she obstructed a lawful arrest, describes her conduct as combative and vulgar, and says she immediately received medical care. Multiple videos of the arrest exist and were the basis of national coverage, but the footage reviewed by reporters does not clearly show the seconds immediately before her arrest, and its audio repeatedly cuts out. No criminal or immigration charges had been filed against Vargas Andrade as of publication, and no charging decision has been announced.
Wear Your Voice
No one is illegal, and no one stands alone. Find the My Voice immigration and No Kings tee in the store at the bottom of this article.
Follow


Privacy Policy · Terms and Conditions · Refund Policy · Shipping Info
© 2025 My Voice Ofc. All rights reserved.
