The House Passed a $1.7 Trillion Spending Law Unconstitutionally, a Federal Appeals Court Ruled
The full Fifth Circuit held on Friday that the House violated the Constitution's Quorum Clause when it passed the 2022 spending package by proxy, and it left in place a block on the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act in Texas.
POLITICS
11/21/20265 min read


Photo: Architect of the Capitol / Public domain
The United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit ruled on Friday, November 20, that the House of Representatives acted unconstitutionally when it passed a $1.7 trillion government funding law in December 2022, because hundreds of members cast their votes by proxy instead of being physically present in the chamber (Reuters, November 21, 2026, https://www.reuters.com/legal/government/us-house-unconstitutionally-passed-spending-bill-2022-court-rules-2026-11-21/). Sitting as a full court, the judges voted 9 to 8 to uphold an injunction that blocks the federal government from enforcing the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act against the state of Texas, the one provision of the law that Texas had challenged.
THE DETAILS
The case is State of Texas v. Blanche, No. 24-10386, decided by the full Fifth Circuit sitting en banc (Bloomberg Law, November 20, 2026, https://news.bloomberglaw.com/us-law-week/congress-proxy-voting-found-unconstitutional-by-fifth-circuit). Judge Cory Wilson, an appointee of President Donald Trump, wrote for the majority. The court held that the Constitution's Quorum Clause requires a majority of House members to be physically present before the House can pass legislation, and that the pandemic era proxy rule violated that requirement.
"While the chambers of the legislature have much discretion regarding their rules of procedure, the Quorum Clause's constraints on congressional power cannot be circumvented by congressional fiat," Wilson wrote (Reuters, November 21, 2026). The majority also held that the enrolled bill rule, the doctrine that courts ordinarily accept an enacted bill's authenticity without looking behind it, did not bar the court from reviewing Texas's challenge (Reason, November 20, 2026, https://reason.com/volokh/2026/11/20/en-banc-fifth-circuit-declares-house-covid-proxy-voting-rule-unconstitutional/).
The relief the court granted was narrow. It barred the Department of Justice and the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission from enforcing the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act against Texas, and it did not disturb the rest of the spending law (Reuters, November 21, 2026). Judge James Graves, an appointee of President Barack Obama, dissented and called the ruling "illogical, inexplicable, and invalid." Graves wrote that the majority had read a physical presence requirement into the Quorum Clause that does not exist, and he asked why, if the whole law was unconstitutionally passed, the judgment should be limited to "one small sliver of the multitrillion dollar bill" (Reuters, November 21, 2026).
BACKGROUND AND CONTEXT
The House adopted proxy voting in May 2020, after the onset of the COVID 19 pandemic, under Speaker Nancy Pelosi, as an emergency measure that let members designate a colleague to cast their vote (Reuters, November 21, 2026). The House used that rule to pass the Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2023, the $1.7 trillion package that funded the government, by a vote of 225 to 201, with 226 members voting by proxy. President Joe Biden signed it into law. Republicans ended proxy voting after they took control of the House following the November 2022 elections.
The Pregnant Workers Fairness Act, one part of that package, requires employers to offer reasonable accommodations to pregnant workers. Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton challenged it, and in February 2024 U.S. District Judge James Hendrix ruled for Texas, holding that the House had violated the Quorum Clause because too few members were physically present for the vote (Bloomberg Law, November 20, 2026). Friday's decision affirmed that judgment. The ruling arrives as Paxton, who brought the case, is leaving office, soon after a Democrat won the Texas attorney general race (Bloomberg Law, November 20, 2026).
WHY THIS MATTERS
The immediate effect falls on pregnant workers in Texas, whose federal right to reasonable workplace accommodations now cannot be enforced against the state. The longer effect is larger. The majority's reasoning is not limited to one statute. It holds that the entire spending act was passed without a constitutional quorum, and legal analysts noted within hours that the same logic could be turned against other laws folded into the same package, including the Electoral Count Reform Act, the post January 6 law that governs how Congress counts electoral votes (Election Law Blog, November 20, 2026, https://electionlawblog.org/2026/en-banc-5th-circuit-decision-threatens-to-hold-electoral-count-reform-act-among-other-laws-unconstitutional/). The majority answered that Texas had asked for relief only against one provision and only for itself. That answer limits this judgment. It does not limit the next lawsuit, and any litigant inside the Fifth Circuit can now cite Friday's ruling.
THE POLITICAL PERSPECTIVE
There is a hard question underneath the partisan divide in this case, and it is worth stating plainly. A quorum rule exists so that a small group cannot legislate in the name of the whole body, and the majority is right that the requirement is in the constitutional text. But the practical consequence of Friday's ruling is that a workplace protection for pregnant women, passed by elected majorities of both chambers and signed by the president, is unenforceable in Texas because of how members were counted during a pandemic emergency four years ago. The workers who lose protection had no say in the House's internal procedures. When procedural rulings land, they land on ordinary people first, and that distribution of costs deserves to be part of how this decision is judged.
THE OTHER SIDE
Supporters of the ruling make a straightforward constitutional argument. The Quorum Clause says a majority of each House constitutes a quorum to do business, and for more than two centuries that meant members in the room. On that reading, the House cannot waive a constitutional requirement by adopting a rule, any more than it could vote by mail. The majority also stressed the narrowness of the judgment it affirmed. Texas challenged one provision, proved an injury from that provision, and received relief against that provision alone. The dissent's answer is that the majority's logic cannot honestly stop there, and that the court has unsettled every law passed under the same procedure while pretending to decide a small case.
WHAT HAPPENS NEXT
The decision is expected to be appealed to the Supreme Court, which would have the final word on whether proxy presence can ever count toward a quorum (Bloomberg Law, November 20, 2026). The Justice Department, which defended the law, did not respond to a request for comment, and neither did the Texas attorney general's office (Reuters, November 21, 2026). Until a higher court acts, the injunction stands: the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act remains in force nationally, but it cannot be enforced against Texas.
SOURCES AND DOCUMENTATION
- Reuters, "US House unconstitutionally passed spending bill in 2022, court rules," November 21, 2026. https://www.reuters.com/legal/government/us-house-unconstitutionally-passed-spending-bill-2022-court-rules-2026-11-21/ Supports the 9 to 8 vote, the injunction, the 225 to 201 passage vote with 226 proxy votes, the Wilson and Graves quotations, and the scope of the relief.
- Bloomberg Law, "Congress Proxy-Voting Found Unconstitutional by Fifth Circuit," November 20, 2026. https://news.bloomberglaw.com/us-law-week/congress-proxy-voting-found-unconstitutional-by-fifth-circuit Supports the case name and number, the 2024 district court ruling, and the expected Supreme Court appeal.
- Reason, The Volokh Conspiracy, "En Banc Fifth Circuit Declares House COVID Proxy Voting Rule Unconstitutional," November 20, 2026. https://reason.com/volokh/2026/11/20/en-banc-fifth-circuit-declares-house-covid-proxy-voting-rule-unconstitutional/ Supports the majority's reasoning on the enrolled bill rule and the Quorum Clause, quoted from the opinion.
- Election Law Blog, "En banc 5th Circuit decision threatens to hold Electoral Count Reform Act (among other laws) unconstitutional," November 20, 2026. https://electionlawblog.org/2026/en-banc-5th-circuit-decision-threatens-to-hold-electoral-count-reform-act-among-other-laws-unconstitutional/ Analysis supporting the discussion of possible challenges to other laws in the same package. It is commentary, and the article treats it as such.
Fact-check note: The judgment itself is narrow, and claims that the entire 2022 spending law has been struck down go beyond what the court ordered. The broader consequences described above are legal analysis of the ruling's reasoning, not holdings of the court.
WEAR YOUR VOICE
Follow


Privacy Policy · Terms and Conditions · Refund Policy · Shipping Info
© 2025 My Voice Ofc. All rights reserved.
