Federal Prosecutors in Western Washington Say They Can No Longer Defend ICE in Many Detention Cases

In an October 26 letter made public this month, Acting U.S. Attorney Charles Neil Floyd told the chief judge of the Western District of Washington that his office lacks the resources to appear in every immigration habeas case and will let judges rule in many cases with no government defense at all. One detainee has already been ordered released under the new approach.

IMMIGRATION

11/16/20262 min read

Photo: U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement / Public domain

Acting U.S. Attorney Charles Neil Floyd told the chief judge of the Western District of Washington in an October 26, 2026 letter that his office can no longer defend the government in many immigration habeas cases. "There will be many habeas cases in which the USAO will no longer assume responsibility for providing a defense on behalf of the respondents," Floyd wrote in the two page letter to Chief Judge David S. Estudillo. The letter was filed as Exhibit A in Singh v. Blanche, No. 2:26 cv 04143, and became public on November 7, attached to an order freeing a detainee.

THE DETAILS

The office will still review and forward court orders, and it reserves the right to appear in a case. If the government does not appear within seven court days, the court may rule on the petitioner's papers alone. Release orders are emailed to the Northwest ICE Processing Center in Tacoma. About 2,000 habeas petitions have been filed in the district since January 2025 through November 3, 2026, according to ProPublica via NOTUS. Dozens of petitions arrive each week, according to the Associated Press on November 10, 2026 via KUOW. Tom Homan estimated about 85,000 habeas petitions nationally, according to the Associated Press, his estimate. Baljit Singh, an asylum seeker from India, was detained in September 2026 after reaching the Canada border exit at Peace Arch. Judge Tiffany M. Cartwright treated his petition as intentionally unopposed and ordered his release within one day, with judgment on November 9. Cartwright knew of no precedent for the Justice Department declining to appear instead of filing a statement of non opposition, and she treated the letter as the department's official position.

BACKGROUND AND CONTEXT

A habeas petition under 28 U.S.C. 2241 challenges detention, not the immigration case itself. The surge tracks denials of bond hearings, according to NOTUS. Floyd was one of four Washington immigration judges who argued for barring bond, a question now before the Supreme Court, according to the Associated Press. Judges in Jacksonville granted 47 habeas petitions in three weeks this fall.

WHY THIS MATTERS

An unanswered petition can end in release on the petitioner's papers alone. The record now holds a documented release plus a written admission that the government will not defend many cases. Judges are ruling on one sided records.

THE POLITICAL PERSPECTIVE

The letter is the administration's own resource math. Detention first policies and bond denial practice generated the caseload. The people held in Tacoma pay first.

THE OTHER SIDE

Floyd's resource argument is real. The office has small civil divisions, faces copied petitions, and says the approach brings faster resolution while preserving its discretion to appear. Cartwright's point is that the normal route is a filed statement of non opposition. The litigation strategy argument does not answer the conceded volume fact.

WHAT HAPPENS NEXT

Watch the Western District of Washington docket, the counts of unanswered petitions and release orders, other districts, Justice Department resources or Congress funding, and the Supreme Court mandatory detention decision.

SOURCES AND DOCUMENTATION

Floyd letter, October 26, 2026, via CourtListener, case record: https://disputeindex.com/cases/western-washington-us-attorney-stops-defending-many-ice-habeas-cases

Cartwright order, November 7, 2026, and judgment, November 9, 2026: https://disputeindex.com/cases/western-washington-us-attorney-stops-defending-many-ice-habeas-cases

Associated Press, November 10, 2026, via KUOW: https://www.kuow.org

NOTUS, November 10, 2026, via: https://www.workersrights.news/western-washington-us-attorney-stops-defending-ice-habeas-cases/

Fact check note: The letter covers the Western District of Washington only. There is no blanket release policy. Unopposed petitions are ruled on by a judge, not granted automatically. The 85,000 figure is an official's estimate reported by the Associated Press, not a verified court statistic.

WEAR YOUR VOICE